‘Underwater’ homeowners lead Sept. foreclosures

By DUANE MARSTELLER - dmarsteller@ bradenton.com

MANATEE — Most Manatee County homeowners who fell into foreclosure last month were financially “under water,” property and court records show.
Two out of every three owed more on their property than what it is worth, according to a Bradenton Herald analysis of property tax records and September foreclosure filings. The average deficit was $72,098.

The Herald’s findings didn’t surprise foreclosure experts, who said Monday that most Florida homeowners have been financially swamped by free-falling home values.

“I would have estimated it as closer to 100 percent,” said Shari Olefson, a Fort Lauderdale foreclosure attorney and author of “Foreclosure Nation: Mortgaging the American Dream.”

The average underwater homeowner in Manatee who was hit with a foreclosure suit in September owed $282,268 on a home valued at $210,170, the Herald’s analysis showed.

In the most extreme case, a bank claims a Michigan couple owes nearly $2.05 million on a Lakewood Ranch Country Club home that’s valued at $1.45 million. And it’s not just single-family homes: The owner of a Bradenton apartment complex valued at nearly $12.1 million is nearly $18.6 million in arrears, according to the lender seeking to foreclose on the property.

Two federal foreclosure-prevention programs have done little to help Florida homeowners because of the eligibility criteria, Olefson said.

With the average underwater homeowner in Manatee owing 134 percent of their home’s value, many don’t qualify for a refinancing program because it’s limited to 125 percent. Federal officials initially estimated as many as 5 million U.S. homeowners could benefit, but only 20,000 loans have been refinanced thus far, according to the Treasury department.

“Most of our properties are more than 25 percent underwater, so refinancing is out of the question for them,” Olefson said.

Another program requires mortgage modifications to cost homeowners no more than 38 percent of their income for the mortgage, taxes and insurance. “That option’s not available for many because our taxes and insurance are so high in Florida,” Olefson said.

The Herald’s analysis was based on each foreclosure case’s “estimate sheet” — the lender or servicer’s calculation of how much the borrower owes — and the subject property’s 2008 market value as determined by the Manatee County Property Appraiser’s Office. The number of underwater homeowners likely is higher, as home prices have fallen further since the property appraiser’s office calculated those values.

Lenders and servicers filed 534 mortgage foreclosure suits in Manatee County Circuit Court in September, eight more than they did in August. They have filed 4,829 such suits through the first nine months of 2009, or 16.5 percent ahead of last year’s record-setting pace.

More than 75 percent of September filings were against homesteaded properties, the highest percentage since the foreclosure surge began in late 2006. Among neighborhoods, Bayshore Gardens had the most foreclosure filings with 11, followed by Greenbrook Village with nine and Greyhawk Landing with eight.